The deficiency symptoms aquatic plants in a tank may show are sometimes difficult to diagnose since the various damages caused by these deficiencies may look very similar and do usually not leave any unequivocal clues as to which specific nutrient might be concerned. This list tries to give an overview over typical problems with nutrient deficiencies in waterplants anyway so you can optimise fertilization to nurse your waterplants back to health and lush growth.
Primarily we can say that a lack of CO2 is partially or even fully responsible for many of the typical deficiency symptoms. We thus assume that a sufficient CO2 supply of 20–30 mg/l is given in your tank. Should you notice that the state of your plants has changed to the negative please check the CO2 supply of your tank first.
When you have made sure that the symptoms of your plants are not due to a lack of CO2, the following schematic list of deficiency symptoms ought to help you identifying the problem.
Nitrogen (nitrate, ammonium, carbamide)
Optimal nitrate levels: 5–30 mg/l NO3
The colour of the waterplant fades to a yellowish green, the older leaves being more yellow than the younger ones. However, the older leaves do not die off.
A strong nitrogen deficiency may show in many ways. Smaller leaves lighter in colour may also point to a lack of nitrogen. Died-off shoots (partially dark-coloured and/or with curly growth) or very slow growth might also be a symptom of nitrogen deficiency.
In some waterplant species, the leaves may also show a reddish discoloration.
Optimal phosphate levels: 0,1–1,5 mg/l PO4
The waterplant stops growing altogether and turns a lighter colour in some parts. Certain waterplants might turn darker, though. Older leaves might show a spot algae infestation and fall off more easily as a rule. Also possible: brown spots on the leaves. Some plant species might turn an intensive purple, as the pigment anthocyanin accumulates. The deficiency symtoms look pretty much like those of nitrate.
Optimal potassium values: 5–15 mg/l K
Smaller necroses form on the older leaves. At the beginning, they are only visible as small black dots, however, they get larger and larger and may have a yellowish rim in some parts. New leaves are reduced in size and surface. In other plant species, the older leaves might turn yellowish before they die off, however, in contrast to a magnesium deficiency, the leaf nerves turn yellow, too.
Optimal iron levels: 0.05–0.1 mg/l Fe
In the case of an iron deficiency, less chlorophyll forms in the new leaves of the waterplants. The leaves and stems are more or less of the same colour. The shoot tips of Ceratophyllum (Hornwort) e.g. first attain a reddish purple stain and then turn white.
The shoots of Egeria densa (Waterweed) first turn a yellowish green to yellow, and its leaves grow smaller. Moreover, the leaves grow very close to the stem.
New growth in Echinodorus species remains smaller in the case of a slight deficiency, and develops lighter-coloured spots or wide longitudinal lighter-coloured stripes.
When the deficiency is more pronounced, the plants tend to have no chlorophyll at all in their new leaves, which die off soon for the same reason. The leaf tissue turns white faster than the leaf nerves, which remain greenish. A strong iron deficiency results in necroses (black spots and holes) in the new leaves, which remain significantly smaller in addition.
Fast-growing plants are the first to show an iron deficiency.
Optimal magnesium levels: 10–15 mg/l Mg
A magnesium deficiency often has the same symptoms as an iron deficiency, as a lack of magnesium blocks the absorption of iron. Heavy chloroses may form. The leaves turn yellow to whiteish and may also have purple discolourations at their tips, and some of them might also show curly growth. These deficiency symptoms may also turn up on young leaves or shoot tips!
Calcium, boron and other trace elements
Optimal calcium levels: 20–30 mg/l Ca
In the case of a calcium deficiency, the new growth on the plants is small and stunted, and the leaf tissue is reduced, however, the leaf nerves remain their original size. The leaves are curly and do not grow smoothly. The new growth may be a very light colour, even white. All in all, though, please keep in mind that there is almost always enough calcium in tap water and that this is a very rare deficiency. A boron deficiency looks very similar to a calcium deficiency, however, it is also very rare as boron is added by any complete iron fertilizer and thus ought to be present in sufficient quantities at almost any time. We will not go into detail on other trace element deficiency symptoms, as a lack of them is almost impossible and should be averted by the use of any complete iron fertilizer. A lack of N (nitrogen), P (phosphorus), K (potassium) as well as iron and magnesium is always more probable and should thus be considered first.